Find the Best Home and Car Insurance Agents in Broken Arrow, Oklahoma
Our top 10 list features verified, licensed insurance agent professionals. Rankings are based on human research, insurance verification, and public record audits.
Top 10 Insurance Agents in Broken Arrow
Verified professionals ranked by our comprehensive research methodology
Farmers Insurance - Derek Venable
Derek Venable is your local Farmers Insurance agent for Broken Arrow, OK, specializing in helping individuals, families, and small businesses identify personalized coverage options for auto, home, renters, business, life, motorcycle, recreational, umbrella, and more. With a focus on straightforward consultations and in-depth explanations of policies, the agency provides tailored solutions to protect what matters most while making insurance decisions easier and smarter for clients.
Pros
- Personalized consultations that explain coverage options clearly and match them to each client's specific needs
Cons
- Standard weekday business hours with no indicated weekend or extended availability
Ray Insurance Agency
Ray Insurance Agency in Broken Arrow, OK offering quick online quotes and dedicated client teams for personal lines (auto, home, renters, boat, ATV, earthquake) and commercial lines (BOP, contractors, builders risk, commercial auto, umbrella).
Pros
- Independent agency with access to multiple carriers for competitive rates and customized coverage options
Cons
- Limited number of public reviews on major platforms compared to larger agencies
Harmon Insurance
Independent insurance agency in Broken Arrow, OK offering personalized auto, home, business, contractors, oil & gas, and commercial coverage with dedicated client teams and quick online quotes from multiple carriers.
Pros
- Independent agency providing access to multiple carriers for customized coverage and competitive rates
Cons
- Standard weekday office hours with no extended evening or weekend availability listed
Greater Tulsa Insurance Inc
Independent insurance agency in Broken Arrow, OK providing comprehensive personal and commercial coverage including auto, home, condo, renters, landlord, flood, umbrella, life, pet, boat, motorcycle, RV, and commercial insurance with personalized consultations to protect assets and limit liability.
Pros
- Husband-and-wife team (James and Kelsey Brown) delivers highly personalized, hands-on service with clients praising their dedication and responsiveness
Cons
- Limited detailed public reviews on major third-party platforms compared to some competitors
Hometown Insurance - Jada Phillips
Women-owned independent insurance agency in Broken Arrow, OK, quoting through 25+ reputable carriers for home, auto, boat, life, and small business insurance with over 15 years of experience and multi-state licensing (OK, AR, TX, KS, MO, CO, TN).
Pros
- Independent agency quoting through 25+ carriers to find the best coverage and rates tailored to each client's needs
Cons
- Standard office hours (Monday-Thursday 9-5, Friday 9-4) with no noted after-hours support
Joe Howard Shelter Insurance
Local Shelter Insurance agency in Broken Arrow, OK, proudly serving the community with auto, home, life, and commercial insurance products. Licensed in multiple states and focused on helping clients obtain the right coverage to protect what matters most.
Pros
- Award-winning local agent recognized as Oklahoma Agent of the Year 2018 with over a decade of dedicated service
Cons
- As a Shelter Insurance agent, coverage is limited to Shelter products only rather than multiple carriers
Swinehart Insurance Agency
Veteran-owned independent insurance agency in Broken Arrow, OK, providing personalized auto, home, business, farm & ranch, workers' compensation, commercial auto, and life insurance solutions. Licensed in Oklahoma and Arkansas with a focus on tailored coverage for small businesses, farms, ranches, and families.
Pros
- Veteran-owned agency with specialized expertise in farm, ranch, and small business insurance including commercial auto and workers' compensation
Cons
- Limited number of public reviews on major platforms compared to larger agencies
The David Pickel Agency - Brightway Insurance
Independent Brightway Insurance agency in Broken Arrow, OK, providing personalized quotes from multiple top-rated carriers for home, auto, renters, condo, life, flood, RV, motorcycle, boat, and umbrella coverage.
Pros
- Independent Brightway agency offering quotes from multiple top carriers for the best coverage and rates
Cons
- Standard weekday hours (9-5) with Saturday by appointment only
Lighthouse Insurance
Independent insurance agency in Broken Arrow, OK, shopping multiple carriers to provide personalized coverage and the best rates for personal and business insurance needs.
Pros
- Fully independent agency that shops multiple carriers to secure the best rates and coverage for each client
Cons
- Standard business hours (Monday-Thursday 9-5, Friday 9-4) with no extended availability noted
AllState - Chris Bonnewitz
Chris Bonnewitz is an Allstate Insurance Agent in Broken Arrow, OK, offering a full range of insurance products including auto, home, renters, life, motorcycle, boat, and business insurance. The agency serves the local community including Tulsa, Bixby, Coweta, Owasso, and Jenks with 10+ years of experience and 20+ years in the community.
Pros
- Exceptional customer service with agents described as professional, knowledgeable, and accessible in verified Allstate reviews
Cons
- Limited number of independent third-party reviews on platforms like Yelp (low review volume)